Classic New England lobster roll with mayo and celery on a toasted bun
SeafoodClassicSummerSpecial Occasion

Lobster Roll

Portrait of food creator Maria Chen

Maria Chen

@mariachencooks

5.0(304 reviews)🍳 2,620 made this

Prep

20 min

Cook

Total

20 min

Servings

4

Difficulty

Medium

Let's cook

  1. Keep the chunks large

    Cut the lobster into large bite-sized pieces, keeping the claw meat as whole as possible. Shredded lobster loses the texture you paid for.

  2. Dress lightly

    Fold the lobster with just enough mayonnaise to coat, plus the lemon juice, celery, chives, cayenne, salt, and pepper. It should look barely dressed.

    💡

    Under-dress it. The lobster is the point, not the mayonnaise.

  3. Chill the filling

    Refrigerate 20 minutes so the flavours settle and the filling firms up.

  4. Butter the sides of the bun

    Spread softened butter on the flat outer sides of each split-top bun and toast in a dry pan for 2 minutes a side until deep golden and crisp.

    💡

    Toasting the flat sides is what a split-top bun is for. This is the whole reason the roll works.

  5. Fill and serve

    Pile the filling into the warm buns, add flaky salt and more chives, and serve with lemon wedges.

🍳

Cook this with Chef Pepe

Want hands-free help? Chef Pepe can read each step, set the pace, answer questions, and help with substitutions.

Try See It. Cook It.

🎙️ Voice-guided cooking mode — coming in Phase 4. Text guidance available now via Chef Pepe.

📝 Tips, swaps, and make-ahead notes

This is the Maine style, served cold with mayonnaise; the Connecticut style is warm lobster in melted butter with no mayonnaise at all, and is equally good. If buying live lobster, steam 8 minutes per pound and chill fully before picking.

  • Cheaper: Langoustine, crab, or good shrimp make an excellent roll on the same method.
  • No split-top buns: Trim the crusts off thick white bread rolls to make flat sides.
  • Make-ahead: The filling keeps a day; toast the buns to order.

Nutrition & Safety

Calories

512kcal

Protein

32g

Carbs

34g

Fat

26g

⚠️ Allergen & Safety Note

This recipe contains shellfish, egg, gluten, dairy and celery. Nutritional values are estimates per serving and may vary based on the specific ingredients you use. If you have food allergies, please verify all ingredients before cooking.

AI-assisted content. Always verify instructions with trusted culinary sources.

Made by the Chew community

2,620 made this
👤

Did you make this? Share what worked, what you changed, and a photo of your plate.

Upload Your Version
Ask Chef Pepe